Costly Solidarity—Close to home and in the Middle East
March 3rd, 2026
By Bishop Jen Nagel
The January morning when Renee Good was killed, I was at the airport, headed for Palestine and Israel for an ELCA accompaniment visit that included the consecration of Bishop Imad Haddad in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Jordan and the Holy Land (ELCJHL). For generations, our siblings in the ELCJHL have experienced daily oppression and violence as they minister in a situation of occupation. Witnessing you and our region move through those days immediately after Good’s death was heartbreaking and beautiful, and the systems—close to home and in the Middle East—that conspire to strip us of dignity and humanity were, and are, palpable.
ELCJHL Palestinian pastor Munther Isaac talks of Costly Solidarity. Standing with another in solidarity has costs: it is risky and, at once, it is the call of our Christian faith. Our call to solidarity is rooted in Jesus’ life and death. Jesus lived in solidarity with those cast down by the systems of power, and he died in solidarity with humanity. Pastor Munther Isaac invited us to this Costly Solidarity, commenting: “We can’t do this alone… You might ask, ‘When do you want us to be here?’ The answer is now. We need you right now.”

ELCJHL Bishop Imad Haddad
After Saturday’s attack on Iran, ELCJHL Bishop Imad Haddad wrote to partners in a powerful and heartfelt letter. One paragraph particularly caught me: “Dear partners, we urge you: pray, and pray fervently. But do not let prayer become a substitute for responsibility. Let your prayers be joined with courageous and concrete action. Stand publicly with those who are afflicted. Advocate persistently for a just peace that safeguards the dignity and security of all people. Challenge policy makers whose narratives make endless war appear inevitable.” Dear ones, this is Costly Solidarity, hearing the need, responding faithfully and boldly for the sake of the Gospel, for the sake of these siblings.
So, what does Costly Solidarity look like here in Minnesota?
Showing Up. Congregations and communities around our synod have been listening and showing up: alongside neighbors, in brave spaces, sometimes quietly for the sake of safety, sometimes boldly, with a persistent resistance in the name of Jesus Christ. I know that folks are tired. And I know that the needs continue. I pray for pacing and resilience. And, please, keep showing up.
Speaking Up. Over these months, on behalf of the Synod (that is all of us), I have spoken up. When I speak as Bishop, I lean into Scripture (the Bible says A LOT about these subjects), into our ELCA social teachings, into the resolutions of our synod (in particular this bold resolution we approved last year at our Synod Assembly that created the Immigration Task Force and Welcome Fund, and asked me and us to speak boldly), and into our baptismal promises (“…to care for others and the world God made, and work for justice and peace…”), and my ordination vows. Recently, the Minneapolis Area Synod joined a lawsuit to ask the government to allow religious leaders to provide pastoral care to those detained at the Whipple Federal Building, similar to how a pastor or deacon would visit someone who is in the hospital or imprisoned elsewhere. We enter this lawsuit confident that its aims are consistent with Scripture, our social statements, our synod’s action, and the promises of baptism and ordination. Pastoral care is at the very heart of what we do and who we are. I know it might feel political to some, but I understand it as Costly Solidarity and part of our call as the Church in the name of Jesus.
Holding Tension. In this moment, we know that we are not all of one mind. Tensions are real when faced with social and political differences, and congregations are navigating these tensions every day. This, too, is part of Costly Solidarity. It asks us to listen well to those who are most affected like our immigrant siblings, to hear one another out, and to live in the tensions of this time and place. I’m moved by the ways Jesus navigated tension during his ministry, and I’m moved by how some in our synod are navigating the tensions in their own communities as well. Again, this is Costly Solidarity. We navigate these tensions trusting in our Savior’s leading and presence.
In Solidarity, not alone. I am in awe of the ways our partners in ministry literally across the Church and around the world are showing up in support of Minnesota and our communities. Daily we receive notes of support, words of encouragement and prayer, and gifts to the Welcome Fund (please do continue to support this fund which has been providing essential resources to congregations serving and accompanying immigrant communities). This accompaniment is powerful, and it reminds me that others are standing in Costly Solidarity with us. We are not alone.
Dear ones, these are challenging times close to home and in the Middle East. I invite you into this Costly Solidarity not because it’s easy—it’s not—but because solidarity is our call. With courage we walk and pray together. Thanks be to God.
















By Bishop Jen Nagel
We share a common calling as church leaders, and we bring with us our particular contexts and experiences, joys and concerns. Though I’m across the ocean, 
By Bishop Jen Nagel
































Holding space.
By Bishop Jen Nagel



By Bishop Jen Nagel